Whoa man! Clarification #4

[ficmod]

NOMINATIONS CLOSE FEBRUARY 20, 10 PM MST.
WHAT TIME IS THAT FOR ME? | COUNTDOWN

We're getting close!

Parade's End/Lord of the Rings Nominators

Do you prefer the tags formatted to books/tv/movies? I need all the LoTR nominators to chime in before I change it. If you don't get back to me by the time sign ups open on Feb 23, I will default to the tags for the books.

Black Jack (Anime & Manga)

Is Young Black Jack (2011) the same franchise? Is it distinct enough from the rest of the canon to be considered separate?

Fantasy VII Nominator/s

Did you intend to use the compilation tag, or do you want it limited to the video game? I will default to the video game tag if I don't hear from the other nominator re: their preference.

Dad's Army / Sector General - James White Nominator/s

The tags "George Mainwaring & Everyone" and "Conway & Everyone" are problematic - is "& Anyone" acceptable?

Star Trek - Various Authors

This canonical tag seems to include all Star Trek novels. Please limit your nomination to a more specific category, such as "Star Trek: The Original Series - Novels" or "Star Trek: Rihannsu."





Note to those wondering about rejected tags: most of the ones I've rejected are because the relationship is already in the tagset under a different format, so double check before you freak out! As always, get in touch if you have questions.

Comments

[rosied]

Sector General - I changed the nom to Conway & Anyone (my brain must have been offline when I did that!). Swapped out Dad's Army for another fandom.

I've changed Star Trek - Various Authors to Star Trek: Rihannsu - Diane Duane

[ficmod]

No worries! Thanks. :)

[(Anonymous)]

Young Black Jack is not part of the main canon, which ended in the 80's. The original author did not draw it, and it is not considered part of the main canon due to not being drawn by Osamu Tezuka.

[(Anonymous)]

It is is style and subject wise very distinct from the original canon.

[ficmod]

Okay, thank you for the clarification!