ficmod: (0)
ficmod ([personal profile] ficmod) wrote in [community profile] waybackexchange 2020-01-28 03:53 pm (UTC)

Adaptations don't count as "new" material, per se, that being said - does the changed ending in 2014 affect the story/characters significantly?

Utena releasing new story in 2019 makes it ineligible, but if the new Sailor Moon is just an adaptation, then that canon would still be accepted.

If a new canon has a different set of characters, then it would count as a separate continuity. However, if the film continues the continuity of the original anime, then that would make it ineligible.

I count separate runs of comics as different canons. You can read through the FAQ for examples, or look at last year's tagset for examples of specific comic runs that I accepted.

My rule of thumb is that if the story is self contained, and has a unique cast of characters, then it would be its own canon. Taking place in the same universe doesn't mecessarily qualify it - Star Trek the Original Series, for instance, technically takes place in the same continuity as the 2009 movie - however, since the characters are significantly different and the new movies don't continue the original story, I considered them separately. You'd have to provide more detail about a specific season/OVA/etc of Gundam if you want a specific answer.

And yes, it never hurts to ask! Requests will be visible during sign ups, as will the sign up summary. What I would ask is for everyone to make sure they're offering something that at least one person is requesting, so that everyone can be assigned a recipient. For requests - if all of them are fairly rare, you might end up on the initial pinch hit list. But I try not to ask people to add more requests unless it's my very last resort.

Post a comment in response:

If you don't have an account you can create one now.
HTML doesn't work in the subject.
More info about formatting